Sixth Annual Meeting
of the
International Association of Medical Science Educators
July 20-23, 2002
Universidad Autonoma de Guadalajara
Guadalajara, Jalisco Mexico
Abstracts on General Education
The following abstracts have been accepted for presentation at this
meeting in Poster format in the category of General Education.
G1 |
THE CULTURE OF MEDICAL EDUCATION – REPORT ON AN INTERACTIVE TRAVELLING
EXHIBITION
Elizabeth Krajic Kachur, Ph.D.* and the International Culture
Exhibition Committee (Michael J Yedidia, Ph.D.; Ernani V. Aboim Silva,
M.D.; Elena Lesser Bruun, Ed.D.; Martin Lischka, M.D.; Athol P. Kent, M.D.;
John H Shatzer, Ph.D.; J Hugh Baron, M.D.; Lisa Altshuler, Ph.D.; Michael
Aylward, M.D.; Nobutaro Ban, M.D.; Peter Schofield, M.D.; Tanya Pagan Raggio,
M.D., M.P.H.; Enoch N Kwizera, M.D.; Alan Hilfer, Ph.D.; Hannah Kedar,
M.A.), Medical Education Development, New York, NY 10010 U.S.A.
The culture of an organization (its manners, customs and values) can
have a major impact on its advancement or stagnation. Educators need
to fully understand their professional and institutional culture in order
to optimize its impact. An interactive exhibition of artifacts (everyday
images and objects of medical education) was mounted in order to help viewers
reflect on the field and their involvement in it.
Medical education conference participants and listserv members were
queried about the images and objects that represent their daily work.
An international committee helped translate these ideas into meaningful
displays. The exhibition was inaugurated at the “Ottawa in Africa”
conference in South Africa (2000). Since then it traveled (sometimes
with an associated workshop) to a North Eastern Group on Educational Affairs
meeting in Hew Hampshire (2000), an Association for Medical Education annual
conference in Germany (2001), a “Quality of Learning” conference in Austria
(2001) and Kings College in England (2001). At three other sites
the project was presented in the form of a poster and sample objects.
Comments and contributions from viewers helped enrich the exhibit in subsequent
iterations. The ultimate goal is a Web-based resource for medical
educators.
Initially the project merely tried to describe the current culture of
medical education. Now it also includes an attempt to explore future
developments. To date the lessons learned include: a) Individuals
engaged in medical education do not routinely reflect on their organizational
and professional work environment; b) Medical education is a very broad
field – familiarity with one area does not ensure familiarity with others;
c) Some objects carry a universal meaning while others seem to have only
regional significance.
|
|
| G2 |
TEMPORAL DYNAMICS OF SOCIETAL SYSTEMS AND REFORMS IN MEDICAL EDUCATION:
FLEXNER, PROBLEM-BASED-LEARNING, AND PERIODIC BEHAVIORS IN ECONOMIES, TECHNOLOGIES,
AND GENERATIONS
R.E. Kinra, Undergraduate University Research Fellow,
Office of Honors Programs, and J.F. Amend*, College of Veterinary Medicine,
Texas A&M University, College Station, TX 77843-4466 U.S.A.
As medical educators strive to prepare qualified physicians who
are responsive to societal needs, systems of medical education continually
reform themselves to meet the demands of changing society. Understanding
the interactions between processes of medical education and behaviors of
surrounding societal systems is crucial to appropriate improvement of medical
education (Ludmerer, 1999). Reforms in medical education provide for constructive
adaptation in the educational system’s process, content, and organization.
Major societal systems that impact medicine and medical education include
economies, technologies, and human generations. Change is often recognized
to occur in these systems with varying periodicities, often producing cyclical
or pulsatile patterns. Numerous studies have analyzed economic “long-waves”
to describe behavior of economies (Kondratieff, 1925; Chevallier, 2000),
invention-innovation cycles to describe patterns in technological advancement
(Marchetti, 1980; Kleinknecht, 1990), and generational cycles to describe
changes in dominant attitudes and values (Strauss and Howe, 1991). In seeking
to discover how medical education responds to such societal changes, this
research analyzes temporal dynamics of two examples of medical educational
reform (Flexner Report; Problem-Based-Learning) in their contexts of coexisting
societal environments. Through evaluation of temporal associations
between cyclic behaviors of societal systems and specific reforms in medical
education, putative cause and effect relationships may be proposed. As
societal systems periodically repeat their behaviors, knowledge of medical
education’s past responses can shed light on current interactions. This
type of analysis may enlighten medical educators and decision-makers responsible
for progress in medical educational institutions and medical curricula.
(Reva Kinra is a Medical Science Scholar, College of Medicine,
Texas A&M University Health Sciences Center. Support from the Office
of Honors Programs, Texas A&M University is gratefully acknowledged.
This work was also supported in part by the Wylie Distinguished Teaching
Professorship in Veterinary Medicine, College of Veterinary Medicine, Texas
A&M University.)
|
|
| G3 |
MEDICAL STUDENT CLASS-PERSONALITY: IT’S INFLUENCE ON LEARNING
R. C. Kolbeck, Ph.D.*, E.W. Inscho, Ph.D., M.W. Brands, Ph.D.,
Department of Physiology, Medical College of Georgia (MCG), Augusta, GA
30912 U.S.A.
The Department of Physiology offers first year medical students
an 11 credit Medical Physiology course as part of the first year curriculum.
The course has been taught to Medical Students ever since MCG was established
as the state’s primary Medical School in Augusta in 1828, by the Georgia
General Assembly. Throughout these years, our department’s teaching
faculty have often remarked about a commonly observed phenomenon – that
is, each class of students, as a group, exhibits a distinct “personality”.
Explanations as to what causes people (and classes) to think, feel, and
behave in specific ways will be left to the social scientists to explain.
Undoubtedly the dynamic interactions of groups of people are influenced
by a variety of factors including the group’s mix of race, religion, gender,
and politics, as well as the influence of the personalities of class and
faculty leaders. Whatever its cause, one thing is certain.
A class’s attitude has a strong influence on its ability to learn.
The primary tenet of this writing is that the attitude of a class of students
can, and must, be influenced in such a way to enhance its ability to perform.
A case in point was presented to us several years ago when a class with
a particular litigious “personality” left both faculty and students discomforted.
Student performance suffered as judged by exam averages. Medical
school administrators responded by creating guidelines that strictly defined
course policies and procedures. A Center for Education Excellence
was created and workshops were offered which taught faculty how to present
lectures and how to write exams. Course directors were encouraged
to serve as student mentors and to maintain an open door policy.
An environment of professionalism and respect was created where the students
were treated as “junior colleagues”. The results have been dramatic
as reflected by a distinct positive change in class attitude and student
performance. Many factors can facilitate or hinder a students ability
to learn. We propose that medical school administrators seriously
consider implementing changes that impact on class personality in such
a way as to promote learning.
|
|
| G4 |
EFFECTS OF A SUMMER LEARNING ENHANCEMENT PROGRAM ON FIRST-YEAR MEDICAL
STUDENT RETENTION
D.L. Weaver, M.A. and D.L. McWhorter, Ph.D.* Departments
of Student Services and Anatomy, The University of Health Sciences College
of Osteopathic Medicine, Kansas City, MO 64106 U.S.A.
The transition from undergraduate education to medical school may present
an insurmountable challenge to underrepresented-minority (URM), disadvantaged
(DA), and nontraditional (NT) students. A growing attrition rate
and a lengthening of undergraduate medical education are critical problems
in medical school education. Commencing July 2000, the Summer Learning
Enhancement Program (SLEP) was implemented at the University of Health
Sciences College of Osteopathic Medicine (UHS-COM) to address these concerns.
The SLEP is a one-week, optional course offered to pre-matriculating URM,
DA, and NT medical students. During the SLEP course, students receive
the first three lectures in Biochemistry, Gross Anatomy, Histology and
Physiology. Moreover, SLEP participants receive instruction on time
management, concept mapping, memory techniques, and test-taking strategies.
Students take a written examination over the 12 basic science lectures
at the conclusion of the SLEP. To date, fifty students have participated
in the SLEP program and none have been dismissed from UHS-COM. Academic
dismissal of first-year students over the past four years (i.e., two years
preceding SLEP and two years following SLEP) has declined from 2.4% to
1.7%. Overall, students have evaluated the SLEP as being extremely
beneficial in their transition to medical school. These preliminary
results suggest that pre-matriculation, academic support programs, such
as the SLEP may offer medical schools a low-cost, short-duration method
for improving student retention, and an equal opportunity for URM, DA and
NT students to succeed in medical school.
|
|
| G5 |
A NATIONAL SURVEY ON THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN BASIC SCIENCE EDUCATORS
AND THE ASSOCIATION OF AMERICAN MEDICAL COLLEGES,
G.C. Rosenfeld, Ph.D.1*, N.K. Krane, M.D.2, J. Menna,
Ph.D.3, B. Weaver, Ph.D.4, Assistant Dean for Educational Programs, University
of Texas Medical School at Houston, Houston, TX 77225 U.S.A.1; Vice
Dean for Academic Affairs, Tulane University School of Medicine, New Orleans,
LA 70112 U.S.A.2; Associate Dean for Medical Education, University of Arkansas
Medical School, Little Rock, AR 72205 U.S.A.3; Assistant Dean, Curriculum
Development and Management, School of Medicine, University of Alabama at
Birmingham, Birmingham, AL 35294 U.S.A.4
Basic science educator (BSE) involvement in undergraduate medical education
is essential. A failure of BSEs to be directly represented in the Association
of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) national and regional meetings where
medical education issues are discussed could leave that important group
in a position from which they can neither contribute to nor profit from
the larger discussions concerning medical education. To clarify this
issue, an electronic survey of basic science course directors at all U.S.
and Canadian allopathic medical schools was conducted. In addition
to obtaining demographic information on the respondents, information was
obtained on their current or past medical education activities (research,
publications, presentations, etc.), their attendance at meetings related
to the teaching of their discipline, the medical education literature they
read, and the extent to which medical education activities are valued,
encouraged, and financially supported by their local institution.
The results of the survey were used to: (1) determine the actual participation
by BSEs in AAMC meetings, (2) examine the BSE relationship, or lack thereof,
with the AAMC, (3) examine how the relationship of BSEs and the AAMC could
be strengthened, and (4) help formulate a set of recommendations for submission
to the AAMC regarding strategies that could be used to include BSEs as
meaningful participants in the dialog to improve undergraduate medical
education.
|
|
| G6 |
USING THE EMOTIONAL STATES ASSESSMENT TECHNIQUE TO INCREASE STUDENTS’
ENTHUSIASM FOR LEARNING
John L. Szarek, Ph.D.*, Department of Pharmacology, Joan
C. Edwards School of Medicine at Marshall University, Huntington WV, 25701
U.S.A.
Purpose: The purpose of my study was to assess first
year medical students’ emotions during learning and to explore ways to
use the results to increase their enthusiasm for learning.
Method: I used the Emotional States Assessment Technique
(Walker, 2001) to assess the percentage of time students (n = 46) experienced
the emotions associated with anxiety, contentment, dejection, and enthusiasm.
The specific events in their learning that caused their emotion(s) were
obtained and coded using themes identified in their comments. Students’
suggestions on ways to increase their enthusiasm about learning also were
collected and coded.
Results: The table summarizes for each category
the percentage of time (mean ± SD), and the emotions and specific
experience themes which received the highest frequency counts (number in
parentheses).
|
Category
|
Percentage
|
Emotion
|
Experience
|
|
Anxiety
|
27% +/- 20%
|
Anxious (38)
|
Performance on test (29)
|
|
Contentment
|
27% +/- 19%
|
Comfortable (28)
|
Accomplishment/completing task (16)
|
|
Dejection
|
12% +/- 10%
|
Weary (32)
|
Long days/amount of information (25)
|
|
Enthusiasm
|
33% +/- 18%
|
Excited (25)
|
Feeling prepared/learning (17)
|
Pertaining to students’ suggestions, they felt that enhancing faculty
teaching skills (19) and better time management on their part (23) would
help to enhance their enthusiasm for learning.
Conclusion: Based on these results, I concluded
that the students’ learning experience, early in their careers as medical
students, is stimulating and that they feel good about their learning.
Further, faculty workshops focusing on teaching skills and student workshops
on study skills would help to increase students’ enthusiasm for learning.
|
|
Return
to Meeting Page
Return to IAMSE Home
Page
|