|
Fifth Annual Meeting
of the
International Association of Medical Science Educators
July 21-24, 2001
Mayo Clinic
Rochester, Minnesota U.S.A.
Abstracts on Instructional Methods
The following abstracts have been accepted for presentation at the this
meeting in Poster format in the category of Instructional Methods.
Those selected for Oral Poster Presentations are so designated in the far
right column.
| A40 |
Hold pending completion of meeting registration process
|
|
| A41 |
VIDEOCONFERENCE SYSTEM BASED ON SATELLITE COMMUNICATION BY SINGLE
CHANNEL PER CARRIER IN AN ARGENTINE SCHOOL OF MEDICINE
Barcelo HA, Feldstein, CA*, Instituto Universitario de Ciencias
de la Salud (Fundacion HA Barcelo) School of Medicine, Buenos Aires, 1205
Argentina
In a private Argentine School of Medicine founded on 1992, composed
of two branches, one in Buenos Aires city and the other in La Rioja province,
740 miles apart from each other, we use a high mean time between failures
satellite system to communicate them, operating all the day around. This
system was designed in support of daily personal education activities of
medical teachers that travel from the Buenos Aires branch to La Rioja branch.
In the year 1999 the student population of the medicine career at Buenos
Aires and La Rioja branches were 1,398 and 773, respectively, and the number
of medical teachers were 308 (102 full-time and 206 part-time) and 128
( 56 full-time and 72 part-time), respectively. The objectives of our videoconference
system based on satellite communication have been to perform interactive
medical education in seminars, case-problem discussions, and CD displaying
for undergraduates, scientific meetings and special careers like computerizing
sciences for postgraduates, and community education programs. The La Rioja
bond has a data transmissions capacity of 192 Kbps that ensures against
loss of imaging in bi-directional controlled emissions. The system uses
equipment for Picture Tel videoconference. In La Rioja a satellite station
of 3.8 meters of diameter working in C band. The central place in the Buenos
Aires branch is connected to IMPSAT Co Teleport, where a master central
station with a high reception sensitivity and great transmission power
allows to get in the remote location an alignment of small stations integrated
with communications satellite Nahuel II and a compact associated electronic
device.
|
|
| A42 |
Abstract withdrawn by author
|
|
| A43 |
INTEGRATION OF CLINICAL TOPICS IN BASIC MEDICAL BIOCHEMISTRY USING
STUDENT PRESENTATIONS
Judith Binstock,.Ph.D.*, Department of Metabolic Sciences,
Division of Basic Sciences, New York College of Podiatric Medicine, New
York, New York, 10035 U.S.A.
The Biochemistry Student Presentations are clinical topics presented
by the students that are intended to show the relevancy of biochemistry
to clinical medicine. Each presentation is assigned to a pair of
students who work together to present their topic to a small recitation
group of approximately 15 students. The topics relate to a Biochemistry
deficiency or disease that correlates to a subject being presented in the
Biochemistry Lectures. The presenters are given general guidelines so as
to incorporate the following points: 1. Discuss the biochemical basis of
the assigned disease or disorder. 2. Search for a case describing
this disorder with laboratory results and present it and compare to normal
values. 3. Discuss what diagnostic tools are used to confirm a diagnosis
in these patients 4. Discuss the treatment plan and long term follow up
for these patients. 5. Discuss the latest research and advancements made
in this area. 6. Discuss the epidemiology and /or genetic association for
this disease. In addition, students must hand in literature searches of
relevant material and articles related to their topic.
The incorporation of this type of recitations into the Biochemistry
course has had many positive outcomes. First, it allows the students to
learn biochemistry from an alternative approach and use it as a tool for
solving and understanding a medical problem or disease. Second, it allows
new information from the internet and other sources that would not normally
be presented in a lecture. Third, it forces the student to organize a presentation
using the latest available technologies such as power point, chime etc.
Fourth, it integrates not only clinical information but other basic sciences
as well. Fifth, this small group setting allows for student interactions
and questions that might otherwise not occur. In conclusion, these types
of small student presentations provide an additional mode of learning that
originates with the student instead of the lecturer and that proves to
be an excellent supplement to the traditional lecture format.
|
|
| A44 |
AN INEXPENSIVE APPROACH TO WEB-BASED HISTOLOGY TEACHING
Angela Y. Bond, B.A., M.S.(R)*, Bernard Pegis, B.A., Vernon
W. Fischer, Ph.D., and Gregory S. Smith, Ph.D., Departments of Anatomy
& Neurobiology and Surgery, Saint Louis University School of Medicine
St. Louis, MO 63104 U.S.A.
Introduction and Objectives: As medical school curricula
continue to evolve, it is incumbent that alternative teaching strategies
be developed to offset time constraints and to maximize new learning technologies.
One type of rapidly developing alternative teaching strategy is web-based
computer instruction. The present study was undertaken to examine novel
methods to produce web-based histology instruction, and to determine the
relative impact of the resultant images by students after completing the
Cell Biology module at our institution.
Methods: Pictures corresponding to a wide range of Cell
Biology topics were taken using a Nikon Eclipse E400 microscope, utilizing
a Nikon Cool Pix 990 digital camera. Once all the pictures were taken,
they were viewed, edited, and labeled (Adobe Photoshop; version 3.0) according
to specific tissue structure and characteristics. Optional captions were
then added explaining the corresponding labels on the images, utilizing
proprietary software developed by one of our students. The labeled and
captioned images were put online for student access. At the completion
of the Cell Biology module, surveys were administered to students to determine
their relative level of satisfaction with this form of computer aided supplementary
instruction.
Results: The students were asked to evaluate the images
based on selection, image quality, labeling, and correlation to class work
on a scale from 1 to 5, with 5 being excellent and 1 being poor. After
analysis
of the data, it was found that the majority of the students felt the
quality, selection, labeling, and explanations of the images were excellent.
When the students were asked to evaluate how well the images correlated
with their class work, 65% indicated an extremely high degree of correlation.
When the students were asked to compare the online atlas to a traditional
atlas, 65% of the students found that the online atlas was better than
the traditional atlas. The final question the students were asked was to
rate how much the images aided them in the class. The overwhelming majority
of the students (97%) indicated that the images aided them in their overall
performance in the class. Some of the students also made comments about
the time it took to download the images. When providing high quality images,
the resulting files are often large, which can lead to increased download
time.
Discussion: The majority of the students indicated the
online histology images helped them in their performance in class. Many
students wrote comments stating they really appreciated the online atlas
format, which included a self-quizzing element. They found this supplemental
teaching approach to be accessible and convenient, particularly for self-study
before exams. Although the students were receptive overall, some felt less
enthusiastic concerning the length of time it took to download the images.
Conclusions: The present study demonstrates the ability
to produce a cost-effective, easily accessible web-based histology atlas.
With the ever advancing changes in accessibility, we expect download times
to decrease significantly, allowing for easier access to such images. Due
to the overwhelmingly positive response from students, we conclude that
this form of web-based computer-aided instruction is a good supplemental
approach to teaching Cell Biology and Histology.
|
|
| A45 |
DEVELOPING AND IMPLEMENTING COMPUTERIZED IMMUNOLOGY CASE STUDIES
John A. Caldwell, Ph.D.* and Louis B. Justement, Ph.D., University
of Alabama School of Medicine Birmingham, AL 35294-0019 U.S.A.
The University of Alabama School of Medicine (UASOM) Medical Education
Committee conducts periodic reviews of all required courses and clerkships.
These reviews encourage course and clerkship directors to increase the
use, and variety, of instructional techniques that require students to
become actively engaged in the learning process. Computerized case
studies offer one strategy to accomplish this.
This poster session will describe our resolution of development and
implementation issues encountered by selecting the computerized case study
strategy. These issues include, but are not limited to: why and how;
setting up a program without a programmer; structuring of the case without
giving the “answer”; motivating students to do and value the cases; program
evaluation and improvement.
|
|
| A46 |
RUBRICS FOR EVALUATING PROBLEM-BASED LEARNING IN THE PRE-CLINICAL
YEARS
Louise M. Canfield, PhD* (Biochemistry), Susan Ellis, MA,
EdS (Division of Academic Resources), Danielle A. DuBois (Curricular Affairs),
Christopher M. Cunniff, MD (Medical & Molecular Genetics/Pediatrics),
University of Arizona College of Medicine, Tucson, AZ, 85724, U.S.A.
Since 1997 Integrated Problem-based Learning (iPBL) at the University
of Arizona College of Medicine has been taught concurrently with traditional
didactic lectures and integrates three of the first-year basic sciences;
Medical Biochemistry, Medical & Molecular Genetics, and Human Physiology.
Grades are pass/fail and based on facilitator evaluation of individual
student’s group participation and written summaries of the cases (case
reports). In course evaluations students consistently gave high ratings
to introduction of clinical topics and the integration of the basic sciences;
however, students were dissatisfied with the variability in facilitators
(level of feedback, consistency in small group experience, consistent grading
of case reports). In addition, iPBL faculty expressed frustration
in the logistics (student preparedness, attendance, tardiness, etc.) and
quality of student participation in small groups.
To address these problems, iPBL teaching faculty (LMC, CMC) collaborated
with an educational specialist (SE) and an Academic Coordinator (DAD) to
develop rubrics for classroom participation and case reports. Rubrics
were modified over the semester in response to student and faculty needs.
In general, the student participation rubric measured small group participation
in four categories: 1-Logistics (on time arrival, preparedness, etc.);
2-Compre-hension (integration of ideas, ability to provide rationales for
contributions, etc.); 3 -Group learning/ participation (sought clarification
for unclear concepts, receptivity to ideas and contributions of others,
etc.); 4-Leadership (synthesized or summarized information for group,
encouraged participation of others, etc.). The case report rubric
focused on three areas: 1-Comprehension of relevant basic science principles;
2- Hypothesis framing and testing; and 3-Development of diagnostic skills.
Students received copies of the participation rubric before the start of
each case. The students were also provided a case report template
at the end of each case that included the rubric items on which they were
to be graded. Likewise, faculty received a "Key" to the case report.
This facilitated grading and decreased variability among groups.
Case report "keys" were returned to the students with their reports
so that they could compare the standard answers with their own
In summary, grading rubrics provided students with clear guidelines
for performance, decreased variability in grading among groups and improved
faculty feedback to students. Faculty reported greatly improved small
group environ-ments: students attended on time, were prepared and
enthusiastic, presented well-researched learning issues, and submitted
clear and concise case reports. Overall, their use appears to have
greatly enriched the quality of the course.
|
|
| A47 |
DEVELOPMENT OF A WORKSHOP TO ENHANCE THE ABILITY OF SCHOOL PERSONNEL
TO DISCUSS BRAIN INJURY AND ALCOHOL ABUSE
David L. Davies*, Mildred Savidge, and E. Robert Burns.
University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences, Little Rock, AR 72205 U.S.A.
The National Institutes of Health funds a program at the University
of Arkansas for Medical Sciences that annually provides K-12 school personnel
with access to a series of one-day workshops held on the medical center
campus and conducted by its faculty. This study evaluated one of these
workshops which was based on the observation that although numerous schools
disseminate information about the risks associated with traumatic brain
injury and alcohol abuse, little is known about the effectiveness of programs
designed to train and equip school personnel to discuss either of these
issues. To address this need, a workshop was offered in the summer of 1999
that focused on the brain, head injury and alcohol abuse. The specific
aims of this workshop were to provide the participants with: 1) current
information about the neurobiological consequences of traumatic brain injury
and alcohol abuse, and 2) instructional resources to enhance their ability
to educate others. An eight-month follow up survey was used to assess whether
and how instructional resources were used by a trained group (n=22) of
volunteer participants. This group was compared with a control group (n=16)
of school personnel that attended workshops concerning other health related
topics, but not the head injury and alcohol abuse workshop. The response
rate to the eight-month follow up survey was 97%. Comparison of the study
and control groups for nine demographic items revealed no statistical differences
between the groups. Consequently, the study participants appeared to be
representative of the population of school personnel that enroll in the
medical center's educational outreach effort. Seventy percent of
the study group was classroom teachers, and the majority of them indicated
in the follow up survey that they had discussed the content of the workshop
with fellow teachers (81%) and students (100%). However, they were less
likely to discuss the information with either an administrator (38%) or
school nurse (25%). Since each participant received a package of instructional
aids, the 8-month survey also assessed how specific instructional resources
distributed at the workshop were utilized. The responses indicated that
visual instructional materials such as laminated illustrations (55%) and
anatomical specimens (45%) were more likely to be used than written materials.
This pilot study demonstrated that a one-day workshop could enhance the
discussion of a specific health related issue among school personnel, and
between them and their students. Further, it showed that teachers have
a strong, and almost exclusive, preference for visual instructional materials.
These findings, coupled with qualitative responses from the participants,
have been useful for developing additional instructional resources that
are cost effective and potentially more likely to meet the needs of school
personnel.
Supported in part by NIH-NCRR grant # 1R25-RR12346 to E.R.B.
|
|
| A48 |
RELATIONSHIP OF LEARNING APPROACH TO PERFORMANCE IN BASIC MEDICAL
SCIENCE EXAMINATION IN A DEVELOPING COUNTRY MEDICAL SCHOOL WITH A TRADITIONAL
CURRICULUM
Asoka S. Dissanayake*, Charmarie Weeraratne, N.Padmalal Gurugama,
Department of Physiology, Faculty of Medicine, University of Kelaniya,
Ragama 11010, Sri Lanka
Student’s approach to their learning has a major
impact on the quality and quantity
of their learning, acquisition of knowledge
and academic performance. Students who consistently
adopted a deep approach were reported to be more
successful in passing examinations than those
who consistently adopted a surface approach. No
information is available on the relationship between learning approach
and basic science examination performance in a developing country medical
school. The medical school at Ragama follows the traditional subject based
curriculum and admits students directly from high school after 13
years of school education where the educational culture is still
one of rote learning. We hypothesized that students using mainly
the surface approach perform better in the final bar examination in basic
medical sciences.
Method: A prospective study was
carried out on a cohort of one
hundred and eighty two students enrolled
in the Second Year of an undergraduate
medical course at the Faculty of Medicine,
University of Kelaniya. The Adelaide Diagnostic
Learning Inventory for Medical Students (ADLIMS)
was administered to this cohort of
students during the last week of the
final term of the Pre-clinical course. The
marks obtained at. the final bar examination , which
was conducted a few weeks later, were then used
to rank the students and divide the
group into poor (bottom 25%), average (middle
50%) and good (top 25%) performers. The responses
to the Inventory questions, the total
marks and the marks obtained for the
individual subjects – Anatomy, Biochemistry and Physiology, along
with marks for separate sections of the Physiology examination at
the final bar examination were entered into a
database. Data were analysed using Epi6.
Results: Data were available from 155 students(86% responses).
As a whole the class did not show a preference for any particular approach.
However, use of the Deep approach correlated significantly with examination
scores in Biochemistry (r=0.2.0, p<0.05) and Physiology (r= 0.25, p<0.05)
but not with Anatomy. Scores for surface approach correlated negatively
with marks in all three subjects. Factorial analysis showed strong correlation
between Factor 3 (which is an indicator of deep approach) and scores in
all 3 subjects. The score for deep approach also correlated significantly
with marks for MCQ, short-essay, OSPE and oral components of Physiology
examination. There was also a strong positive correlation between the use
of the surface approach and marks in the MCQ component. In those performing
poorly, there was a negative correlation between the exam scores and indicators
of disorganised study.
Conclusion: The strong correlation between the Deep Approach
and examination scores suggest that even in a traditional curriculum, examinations
could be constructed to encourage problem-based learning. The results suggest
that MCQ component in Physiology should be modified to test problem-based
learning more than pure recall.
|
|
| A49 |
USE OF PROBLEM ORIENTED LECTURES IN UNDERGRADUATE CLINICAL TEACHING
Muhammad Tufail*, Ziauddin Medical University, Karachi, Pakistan
Objective: To determine the role of problem oriented lecture
as a student-centered, interactive teaching methodology in undergraduate
medical education.
Methods: Third year students of Ziauddin Medical College
were given a scenario based on a case of Intestinal Tuberculosis, which
was relevant to their course objectives. The scenario was given a week
before with the lecture with instructions to come prepared to discuss various
aspects in an interactive session. The study comprised of two parts.
First a three point Likert scale opinion questionnaire covering different
aspects of the lecture was administered immediately after the lecture.
The second part consisted of two surprise tests at an interval of one week
and six weeks after the lecture. These tests were to evaluate the ability
to recall the content and their ability to apply the concepts discussed
in the lecture.
Results: 100% students agreed that the lecture had achieved
all the objectives, the scenario was appropriate to their level of understanding
and that the problem activated their knowledge of basic health sciences.
92% agreed that case stimulated self- learning. 65% student thought that
case based lectures should be given from the beginning of the M.B.B.S program.
77% strongly disagreed with the statement that the objective could have
been achieved by a traditional lecture. In the second part of study
two tests were given to test retention of factual knowledge and application
of knowledge to solving a problem. 100% students were able to recall
50% or more of facts after one week and 96% could do so after six weeks.
87% of the students were able to recall 75% of facts after one week and
52% after six weeks. As for application of their knowledge to solving
the problem 71% could do so after one week while this improved to 92% after
six weeks.
|
|
| A50 |
ESSAY QUESTIONS ON CASE-BASED LEARNING PATIENTS: A MECHANISM FOR
ASSESSING STUDENTS' ABILITY TO INTEGRATE BASIC SCIENCE AND CLINICAL
CONCEPTS
Kristi J. Ferguson, Ph.D.*, University of Iowa College of
Medicine, Iowa City, IA 52242 U.S.A.
Foundations of Clinical Practice I is the first semester of a four-semester
course. Case-based learning, an integrative learning experience, is a key
component of the course. At the conclusion of each of three cases,
students are asked to write an essay about the patient. They are asked
to explain what the diagnosis means in terms the patient can understand,
to describe what the laboratory results and physical findings signify in
relation to the underlying disease process, and to tell the patient what
to expect in the future. This approach allows students to apply both basic
science principles and counseling skills in a context that is very familiar
to them, i.e., a patient case they have spent 3-4 weeks working through
in their small groups. Students have responded positively to the experience.
|
|
| A51 |
TEACHING EMBRYOLOGY IN A TRADITIONAL SCHOOL OF MEDICINE, RESULTS
OF LARGE VERSUS SMALL GROUPS
Carlos E. de la Garza-González *, Norberto López
Serna, Ma. Esthela Morales Pérez, Departamento de Embriología,
Facultad de Medicina, Universidad Autónoma de Nuevo León,
Administración de Correos # 3, apartado postal #712, 64461 Monterrey,
N.L. México
In our country a great number of students have access to public medical
schools every year, that oblige us to create groups with a high number
of students, where a very poor professor-student relationship is developed.
In our faculty, embryology as part of the basic sciences is given in the
first year, therefore we belong to the group of professors who are the
first to be confronted with the situation of the great number of students
who fail to pass the course (about 50%). We have the possibility
of analyze the results of two promotions of medicine students. In
order to elucidate how the number of students for group influence the results
of the examination, since September 1999 we divide the students in four
large (mean 116 and 64 for the first and second promotion respectively)
and two small groups (mean 38 and 30), and analyzed the results of the
examinations. Using the z test at a level of confidence of 95%, in the
groups analyzed, we didn’t find a significant difference of the
results between large and small groups.
|
|
| A52 |
MIXING AND MATCHING DIAGNOSTIC MODALITIES IN MEDICAL STUDENT PATHOLOGY
LABORATORIES
Roger W. Geiss, M.D.* and Steven A. Bigler, M.D. University
of Mississippi School of Medicine, Jackson, MS 39216-4505 U.S.A.
In recent years, traditional laboratory exercises in the basic sciences
have come under increasing criticism by educators as having little or no
direct application to clinical practice. In addition, students have
expressed their dislike for such exercises, not only for the aforementioned
reason, but also because they consider them to be uninteresting as compared
either to direct clinical experience or to computer-based learning.
In response to these factors, we at the University of Mississippi School
of Medicine have devised a low-technology, case-based form of pathology
laboratory exercise in which the manifestations of several diseases within
a single organ system are presented to the students using a number of different
diagnostic modalities, including clinical history, radiologic studies,
gross examination, and/or microscopic study (light, immunofluorescent,
and/or electron microscopic). The students are also provided with
a list of diagnoses, and are given the task of determining the identity
of the clinical history, radiogram, gross specimen, and microscopic specimen
that corresponds to each of the diagnoses listed. Following each
laboratory session, the cases are reviewed with the students by the faculty,
and the students are provided with the correct clinical history and diagnostic
studies for each disease listed. To date, we have successfully utilized
this approach in laboratory exercises related to both renal and bone pathology,
as illustrated. In this way, the laboratory is used as a platform for active
learning and participation. These exercises emphasize the correlation
of clinical, morphologic, and laboratory information in order to aid in
bridging the preclinical with the clinical years. This is done in
a format which the students consider to be an enjoyable learning experience.
We are currently exploring the use of this type of exercise in the teaching
of the pathology of systems other than those we have described.
|
|
| A53 |
TEACHING AND ASSESSMENT OF SURGICAL SKILLS THROUGH SIMULATION IN
SURGICAL TRAINING
A. Goyal, (Senior Resident) MS*, A. Srivastava, (Professor)
MS,FRCS,PhD,MPH, V.M. Seenu,R. Parshad, MS,DNB, and S. Guleria, MS,DNB,FRCS,
All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi-110029, India
Settings: Department of Surgery, All India Institute of
Medical Sciences(AIIMS), New Delhi, India.
Background: Teaching and assessment of technical skills
to the medical students is one of the most crucial tasks. The proper teaching
in operation theatres is difficult due to pressure on theatre time, ethical
issues, medicolegal concerns and complex procedures. Simulation provides
an useful alternative. However the introduction of simulation in surgical
training has been a slow process in developing countries like India. Still,
the operation theatres form the only training grounds and patients the
only models in this part of the world.
Objective: Teaching and Assessment of basic surgical skills
to the trainees in a simulated environment outside the operating room.
Material and Methods: A one day suturing and knot tying
workshop was held, where the students were invited to learn the necessary
knowledge and skills for suturing tissues. Four general surgery consultants
and 3 senior registrars served as supervisors and examiners. The students
were given information on suture materials, needles and various skin suturing
techniques. Students followed this by a hands-on practice session on skin
simulator (foam piece with codrye cloth on top) under supervision by faculty.
The suturing skills of the trainees were assessed before and after the
training by OSCE using the checklist. The checklist consisted of 19 task
steps to be assessed. A pre-training and post training questionnaire was
used to assess their knowledge about sutures and their perceptions about
the workshop.
Results: 32 students participated in the suture and knot-tying
workshop. 14 were MBBS students studying in the 7th semester, and 18 were
junior residents in the general surgery training program of the institute.
All trainees believed that such workshops were useful and should be held
periodically. Most felt (55.6%) the frequency should be once every six
months, 38.9% felt it should once per year, 5% felt it should be less than
once per year. 61.1% felt that the workshop should be held during the beginning
of junior residency, 16.6% felt it should be held during the MBBS course(3rd
year), while 16.6% felt it could be held anytime. 88.9% felt the training
improved their practical skill and theoretical knowledge and would improve
their confidence to do real life surgery. Significant improvement was revealed
in the post training checklist scores (mean 15.3, SD 1.97, median 15, range
12-19) of trainees compared to the pre-training scores(mean 9.9, SD 4.5,
median 10, range 1-16) on wilcoxan signed rank test. The improvement was
more marked for MBBS students. The improvement seen in the post training
questionnaire scores (mean 4.48, SD 2.88, median 5) over the pre-training
scores(mean 4.44, SD2.22, median 4) was not marked on the wilcoxan signed
rank test.
Conclusions: Teaching basic surgical skills in the workshop
setting is both feasible and advantageous using simulation. Basic surgical
skills should be taught to all medical students regardless of their career
aims.
|
|
| A54 |
A STUDY ON OPINION OF MEDICAL COLLEGE TEACHERS ABOUT TEACHING METHODOLOGY
TRAINING
Dr. Md. Zakir Hossain MBBS, MPH*, Senior Lecturer, Community
Medicine Department, Bangladesh Medical College, Dhaka, Bangladesh
This study was carried out among 108 mid level medical college teachers
who had participated in the Teachers’ Training workshop on teaching methodology
conducted by the centre for medical Education. More than 90 percent of
the participants had given opinion in favor of the workshop in terms of
having a good environment, adequate number of participants, taking pre-test
and post-test, use of audio-visual aids and co-operation of the facilitators.
A lesser percentage had agreed with adequacy of duration (50%), course
content (74%) and supplied hand outs (70.3%). They mentioned that these
work shops helped to improve the quality of teaching (63%), helped in self
evaluation and self improvement (59.3%), Helped to realize that quality
teaching is an art and science to be acquired by earnest practice (46.3%).
There was chance to exchange views and ideas among teachers of different
medical colleges in the workshop (26%) and it helped the teachers to be
in pace with the changes taking place in education (20.4%). Almost all
of the participants wanted to attend this workshop again because they wanted
to increase their knowledge about education and be up-dated with new in
formation (94.3%). For improvement of the activities of this workshop,
the participants had recommended that duration of the workshop should be
increased; a training manual should be prepared. Such workshops should
also be held in all medical colleges, teachers of private medical colleges
should also be included in these workshops as participants and residing
accommodations should be made for participants coming to attend the workshop
from out side Dhaka city.
|
|
| A55 |
A COMPETENCY-BASED INTERNSHIP PROGRAM IN BANGLADESH.
Dr. Md. Zakir Hossain MBBS, MPH*, Senior Lecturer, Community
Medicine Department, Bangladesh Medical College, Dhaka; Prof. M. Muzaherul
Huq, Director and Dr. Md. Anwarul Azim Majumder, Assistant Professor, Centre
for Medical education, Dhaka, Bangladesh.
Internship or pre-registration training program is an integral and essential
part for a medical graduate during which he/she develop a range of general
professional skills and attitudes for the practice of medicine. This paper
will be concerned with the redesigning of existing internship program in
Bangladesh to make it more competency based in order to prepare a practicing
doctor with necessary competencies to manage common health problems prevailing
in the community. To develop the programme series of meetings with interns,
their immediate and senior supervisors were held and three surveys were
conducted to obtain the views of interns and their supervisors including
professors of the medical colleges. These results were then taken in consideration
in the formulation of a competency-based internship programme, which was
again validated with the supervisors. The important aspect of the programme
are: training arrangements to include ‘core’ subject, community placements,
assessment and certification, identification of generic competencies, induction
session and log book with task/activities.
|
|
| A56 |
USING A DISTANCE EDUCATION METHOD TO TEACH BEHAVIOURAL SCIENCES
IN A TRADITIONAL MEDICAL SCHOOL
A.P. Kurukulasuriya*, Zoysa de P., Faculty of Medicine, University
of Colombo, Sri Lanka
Introduction: The Faculty of Medicine, University of Colombo
Sri Lanka changed it's subject based teacher centered curriculum to an
organ system based, more student centered curriculum in 1995. The teachers
were thus motivated to explore new learning/teaching strategies. The video
on communication skills for doctor patient relationships with an accompanying
handbook was made as a completely student centered lesson based on principles
of distance education.
Objectives: To create a novel student centered lesson involving
students and experts in the open and traditional universities.
Method: The objectives, script and handbook for the video
were written by the authors. Medical students were selected from volunteers
and were trained to act in the different scenarios for two months. After
which shooting of the video and editing were done by the staff of the open
university.
Discussion: This video has been used to teach a batch of
200 students. We intend to use it for groups of twenty students in a small
group format in the future and compare it's effectivity with a lecture.
|
|
| A57 |
DESIGN OF AN INTEGRATED EVALUATIVE STRATEGY FOR BASIC SCIENCES COURSES
Roberto López, Alvaro Pérez, and Martha García*,
San Juan Bautista School of Medicine, Caguas, Puerto Rico
Basic Biomedical Sciences have shown an explosive growth during the
past ten years. The scientific community has a vast quantity of new information
each day. However, a great number of new data and publications had fragmentized
the knowledge and generated difficulties to understand the physiological
and pathological process of life. Today, scientific groups are working
in the search of common pathways in the biomedical sciences. New disciplines
had emerged, such as neuroimmunogenetics, immunoendocrinology, neuropharmacology,
pharmacogenetics, etc., Medical education needs continuous updates according
to this scientific transformation. With the aim to find new teaching-learning
methodologies for a new generation of medical students, within the context
of a traditional medical curriculum, we designed a new strategy integrating
three basic sciences courses (Human Genetics, Neurosciences and Immunology).
Also, this methodology reinforces the importance of basic research in the
formation and future performance of physicians. The methodology includes
a workgroup, developed through an academic semester, in which the students
present a research proposal according to the scientific method and including
the three disciplines. The instructors, will evaluate progress aims during
meetings and interactive communication, and will supervise the process.
The work has several progressive steps according to the development of
each course objectives, as follows:
1. Theme selection
2. Methods selection
3. Poster Design
4. Final Presentation in
a symposium to medical students, professors, and guests.
The benefits of this strategy include critical revision of the literature,
learning of basic research methodologies, use of informatics in medicine,
scientific presentation methods (oral and written), critical evaluation
of medical information trough a peer review process, that includes evaluation
of his colleague's posters using a form designed to this activity, knowledge
of scientific methodology, approach to complex problems solving, and accomplishment
of new curricular strategies. We will illustrate the background, general
design and results of this methodology.
|
ORAL |
| A58 |
Hold pending completion of meeting registration process
|
|
| A59 |
DISTANCE LEARNING IN MEDICAL EDUCATION – IS A FACE-TO-FACE
COMPONENT ESSENTIAL?
Win May, MD, PhD, MHPEd, MMedSc*, Dixie Fisher, PhD, Maurice
Hitchcock, EdD. University of Southern California Keck School of Medicine,
Los Angeles, California 90033 U.S.A.
The Faculty Development Program for health professions educators at
the Division of Medical Education, University of Southern California Keck
School of Medicine is a well-established program that has been in existence
for over thirty years. For most of that time, the Division offered a conventional
on-site Master’s program, a supplemental part of the Ph.D./Ed.D programs,
and short-term individual training for national and international participants.
In 1998, as a result of numerous requests from health professionals
outside the local area, the Division implemented a program that was a hybrid
of distance and face-to-face learning. To increase flexibility, a number
of options were offered: a Master’s degree, a fellowship in Teaching and
Learning, a fellowship in Educational Leadership, as well as attendance
at individual workshops.
Since acquisition of skills is required to become an excellent teacher,
face-to face sessions on key topic areas were an integral part of the program.
The distance learning portion utilized the web, e-mail, postal services
and the telephone as the modes of delivery for both instruction and communication
between faculty and students and between the students themselves. The Master’s
program is a two year program for participants from the United States,
whereas, international students can complete the program in a year, doing
it full-time. The latter group participated in additional weekly face-to-face
discussions with a faculty member.
Focus group discussions were conducted at the end of each year to determine
the value of both the face-to-face instruction and the distance learning
aspects.
|
ORAL |
| A60 |
UNDERSTANDING FUNDAMENTALS OF EXTREMITY ANATOMY- AN EVALUATION
Dr. Narga Nair* and Mrs. Shreemathi Y. *Associate Professor,
Department of Anatomy, & Senior Lecturer, Department of Medical Education,
Kasturba Medical College, Manipal, India
It is important for a medical student to gain competence in skills like
carrying out a venepuncture, an arterial puncture, palpate an enlarged
lymph node, a peripheral nerve, or arterial pulsation, recognize the presence
of varicose veins, exaggerated tendon reflexes, a foot drop or a shoulder
dislocation. For the above to take place the student needs to have
a firm foundation of knowledge in the anatomy of the upper and lower limbs.
It is on this corner stone that the superstructure of clinical medicine
may well rest secure. It is in this context that we proceeded with
the present investigation.
Aim: To strengthen the fundamental knowledge of anatomy
of the upper and lower limbs, so as to provide a more effective clinician
to the world.
Objectives:
-
To assess recall of basic factual data with regard to the anatomy of the
upper limb.
-
To test understanding of basic clinical principles as applied to the upper
limb.
-
To assess recall of basic facts with regard to the anatomy of the lower
limb.
-
To test understanding of basic clinical principles as applied to the lower
limb.
Method: 200 freshman medical students having completed their
anatomy modules of the upper and lower limbs, were given a questionnaire
of 10 questions (of fill in the blank type), for formative evaluation,
which they were able to complete in 5 minutes. The difficulty index
and the discrimination index of each of the ten questions were assessed.
The results of the study and their implications thereof will be presented
at the conference.
|
|
| A61 |
INTRODUCTION OF CLINICAL PROBLEM SOLVING IN AN INTEGRATED NEUROSCIENCES
CURRICULUM, THE MOUNT SINAI EXPERIENCE
Daniel P. Perl*, Merril Schindler, Mount Sinai School
of Medicine, New York, NY 10029 U.S.A.
Brain and Behavior, an integrated neurosciences course in the second
year of medical school, is charged with teaching the basic tenets of neuroanatomy,
neurophysiology, neurohistology, neuropathology, and pathophysiologic methansims
underlying clinical neurology and psychiatry. In the past, the course
has been taught using a strong combination of didactic lectures and laboratory
exercises. We have now added a series of small group clinical neuroanatomy
problem solving sessions in an attempt to supplement the material being
taught in the course. We use these sessions to introduce clinically
relevant patient vignettes and develop clinical problem solving skills
in the students. A total of 14 sessions have been written, each typically
encompassing 2 illustrative patients. The theme of each session closely
parallels the topics being considered, at that time, in the course.
For each patient, a brief history and summary of the physical findings
are provided, often followed by relevant imaging studies (typically in
direct parallel with specimens just examined by the students in the laboratory).
When available, a short video of the patient under discussion is also included.
The students are then directed to consider a series of problems, frequently
requiring them to investigate aspects that are beyond what has been specifically
covered in the course. Protocols for these exercises are provided
to the students by way of a course web site. Each session culminates
with a two hour interaction with a clinician preceptor, in a small group
setting. The sessions emphasize defining each patient in the
context of structural/functional relationships, rather than considering
clinical diagnostic and therapeutic algorithms. We urge our preceptors
to encourage discussion among the students and guide them in reaching solutions
to the problems raised. Acceptance of these sessions, as an addition to
the course, has been excellent with many students indicating that they
provide an opportunity to see the clinical relevance of the basic science
material they are trying to learn. Small group preceptors relate
their feeling that participation in these sessions has promoted a progressive
improvement in problem solving skills among the students and an enhanced
ability to discuss clinical situations using the facts and principles they
have learned. Students also indicate an increasing interest in considering
the clinical neurosciences as a career choice. Based on this success,
we plan to expand the use of this approach to the learning environment
of this course.
|
|
| A62 |
CASE-BASED LEARNING IN BIOCHEMISTRY
Peter Ronner*, Diane Merry, and Annemarie Weber**; Thomas
Jefferson University, College of Medicine, and ** University of Pennsylvania,
School of Medicine, Philadelphia, PA U.S.A.
On exams, students can easily recall biochemical facts, but usually
have difficulty using these same biochemical facts to solve medically relevant
problems. To improve students’ problem solving abilities and
aid in long-term retention of medical biochemistry, we designed a series
of case-based problem sets (some of these originated at the University
of Pennsylvania, others at Thomas Jefferson University). We hand out the
problem sets in advance and ask the students to answer as many questions
as possible. Only the best students are able to answer all questions, but
the questions are designed so that every student is able to answer at least
20-30% of the questions. The problem set is then discussed in class. The
faculty welcome all answers, even if incorrect, recognizing the value of
discussing why an answer is incorrect. Whenever feasible, students are
encouraged to comment on other students’ opinions. At the conclusion
of the discussion of a question, it is important for the lecturer to state
clearly which answers are considered correct and which ones not. We currently
discuss the problem sets in a large class of ~230 students; however, the
problem sets are ideally suited for small groups. In creating problem sets,
in our experience, it is best to use only one or two cases for a 1-hour
discussion. We use published case histories and in-house hospital charts
as a basis for our problem sets. Published cases most often involve newly
discovered clinical entities and uncommon diseases, while hospital charts
are more valuable for up to date histories of common diseases. Students
respond better to problems dealing with common diseases than to problems
involving rare diseases, even if these rare diseases illustrate important
principles of biochemistry. We prefer case histories that contain graphic
material, such as a picture of a patient, a pathological specimen, or a
radiologic procedure; these are generally more common in the older literature.
At the end of a problem set, the students are asked to sum up the case
and explain the relevant information. The students are also asked to familiarize
themselves with the approximate normal ranges of the most common laboratory
tests. To date, at Thomas Jefferson University, we have problem sets on
trinucleotide repeat diseases, hypophosphatemia/glycolysis, glucose 6-phosphate
dehydrogenase deficiency (with a review of enzyme kinetics), glycogen debranching
enzyme deficiency, insulinoma (review of glucose homeostasis), ketotic
hypoalaninemic hypoglycemia of children (review of gluconeogenesis), abetalipoproteinemia
(review of lipid metabolism), diabetic ketoacidosis, preeclampsia (review
of purine metabolism), propionyl-CoA carboxylase deficiency, and glucagonoma
(the last two for overall reviews of metabolism).
|
ORAL |
| A63 |
PATIENT-CENTERED PHYSIOLOGY SMALL GROUPS - CLINICAL ASPECTS OF PHYSIOLOGY
Nancy R. Stevenson*, David J. Riley and Mark J. Greco.
University of Medicine & Dentistry of New Jersey-Robert Wood Johnson
Medical School, Piscataway, NJ 08854 U.S.A.
To achieve better integration of basic and clinical aspects of medical
physiology, we have added videotaped interviews of patients to supplement
small group case studies. The purpose of the videos is to illustrate
the symptoms of the disorder in the patient's functioning and other clinical
aspects of the disease. In general, the cases are of commonly seen
disorders and/or demonstrate the involvement of more than one organ system.
Some cases are chosen with specific biochemical defects (eg. alpha-1-antitrypsin
deficiency and pheochromocytoma) that directly cause physiologic consequences
(emphysema, hypertension). Other cases illustrate the clinical consequence
of physiologic processes (right heart failure caused by hypoxia-induced
lung disease).
The videotapes (15 - 25 minutes) include an interview, illustrating
the pertinent physiological findings, radiographic and relevant laboratory
test results. Normal subjects are included for the purpose of comparing
physical findings and test results. A clinician involved with the
case, or one familiar with the case moderates the video with the students
and answers student questions not directly related to the activities of
the subsequent small group discussions. The videos are available
for the students to review until the case is finished.
In the small groups, students have a copy of the case and any X-rays
or films used for the diagnosis. At the first meeting, a facilitator
and a group of 8 to 10 students discuss the case and the each student chooses
a question he/she would like to pursue. At the second meeting, each
student presents a 5 minute oral answer to the question and prepares a
1 page answer to be handed out to the rest of the group. The two
meeting are separated by about one week.
This format was designed to address several curricular and pedagogical
needs. 1) How to provide a link between altered physiology
and its clinical impact on patients. 2) How to integrate clinical
role models in the first year of the curriculum. 3) How to
insure uniformity of material for small group sessions when the facilitator
is a non-clinician. 4) How to integrate physical findings as
part of the evaluation the of clinical problems.
We have found video-supplemented small groups case conferences to be
an effective teaching method for medical physiology. These exercises
are enriched by showing vivid tapes of patients affected by physiological
alterations of organ function. The student's response to these Patient-Centered
Physiology Small Groups is more positive and enthusiastic than to "paper
case studies". Several students speak of these as "real cases".
|
ORAL |
| A64 |
DEVELOPMENT OF TEACHING TOOLS FOR MEDICAL EDUCATION
Katherine H. Taber, Ph.D.*, Robin A. Hurley, M.D., L. Anne
Hayman, M.D., Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, TX 77030 U.S.A.
The volume of medical knowledge increases massively every year, creating
a real problem with information overload for learners at all levels from
medical students to practicing physicians. One approach to this problem
is to improve didactic teaching and support materials so that information
is presented in a more concise and organized manner, facilitating development
of a properly structured knowledge base and obviating the need to relearn
material when the student enters the clinical setting. Most teaching
and reference materials are still based upon the oldest of the print technologies
- block print on a white page with at most occasional use of color to lighten
up the often dry prose. Most are presented in a way that would be quite
familiar to a physician from 50 or 100 years ago. Advances in printing
and computer graphics technology have made it possible to create teaching
and reference materials in a very large page format, like a wall chart,
relatively easily. This approach allows a great deal of related information
to coexist simultaneously in the learner's field of view. Extensive use
of graphics promotes a highly condensed presentation of information. By
careful application of the principles of information design it is possible
to arrange material so as to make the connections among the blocks of information
obvious and easily grasped. Thus the design and presentation of the information
helps to create the scaffold the learner needs in order to integrate the
it into their own knowledge base in an organized manner. An additional
advantage of this approach is that it makes it possible to use color to
carry a significant portion of the information content. When color is used
informatively in teaching and reference materials (rather than decoratively
or for emphasis) it can greatly increase the speed of access as well as
broaden the relevant information that will be easily found. For the
past seven years our group has been using the principles of information
design in creating sets of teaching and reference materials that integrate
related information across clinical subspecialties. These charts organize
and synthesize anatomy with function in a way that bridges across disciplines
in a "user friendly" format that enriches teaching. This approach facilitates
the learning process by providing a memorable basis for organizing new
information to form an elaborated knowledge base. In addition, all anatomy
is presented as it is seen clinically, allowing the charts to be used for
rapid clinical reference. Chart set on functional anatomy of the brain
and spine, vascular anatomy of the brain and spine, and sectional anatomy
of head and neck will be presented.
|
|
| A65 |
THE EFFECT OF INCREASED CLINICAL CORRELATION TEACHING ON STUDENTS’
PERFORMANCE IN THE DEPARTMENTAL AND NBME SUBJECT EXAMINATION
N.S. Vasan, DVM, PhD*, Department of Anatomy, Cell Biology
and Injury Sciences, University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey,
New Jersey Medical School, Newark, NJ 07103 U.S.A.
Basic science curriculum in medical schools around the world is increasingly
being taught with clinical correlation in order to provide a seamless transition
from preclinical-to-clinical years. Furthermore, the standardized tests
for basic sciences (USMLE Step I), which in part tests the critical thinking
skills of the student, is also clinically oriented. At New Jersey
Medical School the Department of Anatomy took the lead in curriculum enhancement.
This was done by decreasing the amount of didactic material, increasing
the focus on laboratory teaching by way of small group interactive teaching,
and increased clinical correlation both in teaching and in departmental
course examinations. The purpose of this performance-based retrospective
study is to evaluate the effectiveness of curriculum reform, and to identify
additional directions for continuous improvement. Over the last five years
the clinical vignettes in the multiple choice questions in the in-house
examinations increased from 25% in 1997 to 90% in 2001. The data to be
presented involves analysis of the class performance in both departmental
and NBME subject examinations. The results indicate that increased incorporation
of clinical correlation teaching both in lectures and laboratory, and testing
substantially increased student performance in the in-house and NBME subject
examinations. The results further indicate that initially some students
had difficulty in adjusting to the application of factual material, however
constant practice in problem solving helped them to overcome this difficulty.
We believe that the anatomy program encourages and helps the students develop
problem solving skills, and promote life long learning. Data from a study
in progress also suggests that even in student-centered learning, knowledge
gained in isolation does not allow long-term retention, unless it stimulates
critical thinking linked by clinical correlation to the learning process.
|
ORAL |
| A66 |
ASSOCIATION OF REMEDIAL TUTORIAL TO STUDENTS AT RISK OF FAILING
ANATOMY AND THEIR IMPROVED PERFORMANCE
N.S. Vasan, DVM, PhD*, Department of Anatomy, Cell Biology
and Injury Sciences, University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey,
New Jersey Medical School, Newark, NJ 07103 U.S.A.
The Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) in 1984 recommended
curriculum changes at all traditional medical schools toward student-centered,
problem-based learning with an integration of basic and clinical sciences.
This is done by reducing didactic material, and increasing the emphasis
on teaching concepts and principles, and helping students develop problem
solving skills. The gross and developmental anatomy course at New Jersey
Medical School is a very highly clinically correlated course. To perform
well in the course, the students need to have basic cognitive skills in
acquisition of knowledge, problem solving, hypothesis generation, interpretation
and clinical reasoning. When students are confronted with such a demand
during the early part of their medical schooling, acquisition of such a
cognitive competency varies to a high degree among them. For some of the
students, this resulted in an inability to cope with the new expectations
which were very different from their undergraduate learning style. These
students experienced failure in the early part of the program. In spite
of a rigorous selection process to medical school admission, studies have
shown that the existing prediction models on student performance have limitations.
At New Jersey Medical School during 1997-2001between 10-15% of the first
year students who have taken gross anatomy failed the first unit examination
which is given five weeks into the program. These students who are at risk
of failing the course were provided with highly structured, interactive
remedial tutorials that specifically involved the application of factual
knowledge to clinical problem solving. The purpose of this study is to
evaluate the effectiveness of such an intervention. The results to be presented
involves an analysis of the remediators performance in subsequent departmental
examinations and the NBME subject examination. The results indicate that
in the last five years 124 students failed the first anatomy examination.
When entered into the remedial program 105 (85%) successfully completed
the course. Of the remaining 19 students, three left the school, five successfully
completed the summer makeup examination, and eight students repeated the
first year due to multiple course failures. No decision has been made on
the remaining three students who are still completing their first year.
In conclusion, early identification of those students who were at risk
for failing anatomy who then took part in the structured remedial tutorial
program were successful in passing the course. The key to success of the
remedial program in improving cognitive skills is delegating to students
the responsibility of knowledge acquisition, and facilitating an interactive
group process in which the knowledge is applied to clinical problem solving.
|
|
|